In 2017, A.J. overheard caddy Brian “Sully” Sullivan making disrespectful comments about Trump during the Senior PGA Championship. Sullivan allegedly said, “I hate that motherf—–!” about Trump. A.J. reacted by confronting Sullivan, putting him in a chokehold, and yelling, “You’re not gonna come to Mr. Trump’s course and eat Mr. Trump’s food and then use the word ‘hate’ about my president.”
Sullivan later admitted his memory was unclear, partly because he might have been hungover, and explained that he didn’t want to be on a Trump course. Eventually, the two made amends.